Changes

* Other characteristics

* Other characteristics

** Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT)

** Open-Source Intelligence (OSINT)

==Public Comments==

===Public Comments===

From late January to mid-March 2022, the NCAP Discussion Group sought [[Public Comment]]s on two draft work products related to NCAP Study 2 goals of understanding how measurements of DNS hierarchy layers can convey the impact of name collisions.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/en/public-comment/proceeding/name-collision-analysis-project-ncap-study-2-documents-27-01-2022 NCAP Study 2 Public Comment Proceedings, ICANN]</ref> The group received 3 comments on the topics of:  

From late January to mid-March 2022, the NCAP Discussion Group sought [[Public Comment]]s on two draft work products related to NCAP Study 2 goals of understanding how measurements of DNS hierarchy layers can convey the impact of name collisions.<ref>[https://www.icann.org/en/public-comment/proceeding/name-collision-analysis-project-ncap-study-2-documents-27-01-2022 NCAP Study 2 Public Comment Proceedings, ICANN]</ref> The group received 3 comments on the topics of:  

# A Prospective Study of DNS Queries for Non-Existent Top-Level Domains to understand the distribution of DNS name collision traffic throughout the DNS hierarchy and determine where and how to collect and assess DNS data.

# A Prospective Study of DNS Queries for Non-Existent Top-Level Domains to understand the distribution of DNS name collision traffic throughout the DNS hierarchy and determine where and how to collect and assess DNS data.

# Case Studies of Collision Strings (.corp, .home, .mail, .internal, .lan, and .local) based on DNS query data from A and J root servers in light of DNS evolution.<br/>

# Case Studies of Collision Strings (.corp, .home, .mail, .internal, .lan, and .local) based on DNS query data from A and J root servers in light of DNS evolution.<br/>

[[OCTO]] suggested specific amendments to the documents whereas the [[ISPCP]] and [[RySG]] gave high-level statements about the group’s approach. OCTO noted that the study descriptions are not related to understanding the root cause of most name collisions, and this relationship should be spelled out. OCTO also advised the group that the documents should be revised to specify quantitatively which, if any, of their findings had a significant impact on the RSS, end users, or resolvers. OCTO encouraged the group to support all conclusions with data.<ref>[https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/name-collision/nacp-study-2-documents-04-04-2022-en.pdf NCAP Study 2 Drafts, Public Comments, ICANN]</ref> The ISPCP suggested the discussion group should be expanded to include representatives from other parts of the [[ICANN Community]]. RySG supported the continued use of the hypothesis that "controlled interruption is effective" based on the data.<ref>[https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/name-collision/nacp-study-2-documents-04-04-2022-en.pdf NCAP Study 2 Drafts, Public Comments, ICANN]</ref>

[[OCTO]] suggested specific amendments to the documents whereas the [[ISPCP]] and [[RySG]] gave high-level statements about the group’s approach. OCTO noted that the study descriptions are not related to understanding the root cause of most name collisions, and this relationship should be spelled out. OCTO also advised the group that the documents should be revised to specify quantitatively which, if any, of their findings had a significant impact on the RSS, end users, or resolvers. OCTO encouraged the group to support all conclusions with data.<ref>[https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/name-collision/nacp-study-2-documents-04-04-2022-en.pdf NCAP Study 2 Drafts, Public Comments, ICANN]</ref> The ISPCP suggested the discussion group should be expanded to include representatives from other parts of the [[ICANN Community]]. RySG supported the continued use of the hypothesis that "controlled interruption is effective" based on the data.<ref>[https://itp.cdn.icann.org/en/files/name-collision/nacp-study-2-documents-04-04-2022-en.pdf NCAP Study 2 Drafts, Public Comments, ICANN]</ref>

 

==References==

==References==

{{reflist}}

{{reflist}}

[[Category:Glossary]]

[[Category:Glossary]]