Changes

Prioritization Framework (view source)

Revision as of 19:46, 21 April 2022

3,886 bytes removed , 2 years ago

→‎Recommendations Considered during the Pilot

Line 63: Line 63:

! style="background-color:#D9EAD3;" | ICANN Org Priority Level P1 = highest priority P4 = lowest priority

! style="background-color:#D9EAD3;" | Rationale

−

~~! style="font-style:italic;" | Level of Urgency~~

−

~~! style="font-style:italic;" | Level of Importance~~

! ICANN COMMUNITY PPG Priority Level P1 = highest priority P4 = lowest priority

! Rationale

Line 72: Line 70:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | Based on the current [[ICANN Bylaws]] requirement, the next [[Second Registration Directory Service Review|RDS Review]] (RDS3) is in Sep 2023, but all further RDS review should be suspended for now.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 13 Apr 2022

Line 81: Line 77:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | Redesigns the process of reviews.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 13 Apr 2022

Line 90: Line 84:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | Requires [[ICANN Board]] action and differs from what is currently stated in the ByLaws.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 13 Apr 2022

Line 99: Line 91:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | Essential to have a framework in place for data collection

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 19 Apr 2022

Line 108: Line 98:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | Recommendations 8, 11, 13 items 1, 2, 4 to be handled in a single implementation. Recommendation 11 is a prerequisite

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 19 Apr 2022

Line 117: Line 105:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 19 Apr 2022

Line 126: Line 112:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 19 Apr 2022

Line 135: Line 119:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | need a common community understanding of what is [[DNS Abuse]] and [[cybercrime|related terms]]

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 19 Apr 2022

Line 144: Line 126:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | Efforts to implement the new [[Root Zone]] Management System are already underway. This recommendation will build on existing efforts to enhance security in the Root Zone System.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agreed - 19 Apr 2022

Line 153: Line 133:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | Need time to develop template and structure for this new reporting rerquirement

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agree with ICANN org pre assessment. - 19 Apr 2022

Line 162: Line 140:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agree with ICANN org pre assessment. - 19 Apr 2022

Line 171: Line 147:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agree with ICANN org pre assessment. - 19 Apr 2022

Line 180: Line 154:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agree with ICANN org pre assessment. - 19 Apr 2022

Line 189: Line 161:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | Agree with ICANN org pre assessment. - 19 Apr 2022

Line 198: Line 168:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | determined by CCT-RT to be a high priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Urgent~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Less Important~~

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | - 19 April 2022

Line 207: Line 175:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | needs to be run as a pilot first, to be designed with the community.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FF0; text-align:left;" | obtained consensus on "Importance"; not yet obtained consensus on "Urgency" - 13 Apr 2022

Line 216: Line 182:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | New review/program to be designed with each individual [[SO]]/[[AC]]/[[NomCom|NC]]

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" | Important~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FF0; text-align:left;" | obtained consensus on "Importance"; not yet obtained consensus on "Urgency" - 19 Apr 2022

Line 225: Line 189:

| style="background-color:#E06666;" | P1

| style="text-align:left;" | This recommendation about [[RDAP]] is rated by the RDS-WHOIS2 as high.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FF0; text-align:left;" | skip for now due to lack of information - 19 April 2022

Line 234: Line 196:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | fold into a voluntary pilot survey of [[CPH|contracted parties]].

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 243: Line 203:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8; text-align:left;" |

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 252: Line 210:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 261: Line 217:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 270: Line 224:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8; text-align:left;" |

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 279: Line 231:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | rated by the CCT-RT as high.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 288: Line 238:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 297: Line 245:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 306: Line 252:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | included in the next round of contractual negotiations with the contracted parties

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 315: Line 259:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 324: Line 266:

| style="background-color:#B6D7A8;" | P2

| style="text-align:left;" | determined by SSR2 as a medium priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 333: Line 273:

| style="background-color:#C9DAF8;" | P3

| style="text-align:left;" | determined by CCT-RT as a low priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 342: Line 280:

| style="background-color:#C9DAF8;" | P3

| style="text-align:left;" | determined by CCT-RT as a low priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 350: Line 286:

| Rec 16.1

| style="background-color:#C9DAF8;" | P3

−

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | May include dependencies on [[Expedited Policy Development Process on the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data|EPDP related work]]

+

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | May include dependencies on [[Expedited Policy Development Process on the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data|EPDP related work]]

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 360: Line 294:

| style="background-color:#C9DAF8;" | P3

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | Dependent on completion on SSR2 Review Rec 23.2.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 369: Line 301:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | implemented in 2021

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 378: Line 308:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 387: Line 315:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | determined by ATRT3 as a low priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 396: Line 322:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | Work is underway to determine which measures are needed to ensure that appropriate information on Caucus group activities is provided to the community.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 405: Line 329:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | Updates to web documentation were made - action needed on the need to include users/focus groups.

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 414: Line 336:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 423: Line 343:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | ICANN org conducted a study on the topic of [[Expedited Policy Development Process on the Temporary Specification for gTLD Registration Data#EPDP Phase 2A|differentiation of legal vs. natural persons' registration data]]; two surveys on the Standardized System for Access and Disclosure ([[SSAD]]) Operational Design Phase ([[ODP]]). ICANN org is working on streamlined [[AC#Procedure and Process|mechanisms to request, receive, and gather feedback]] from the community and stakeholders

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 432: Line 350:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | ditto

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 441: Line 357:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | already implemented or need to be retired due to Internet landscape changes

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 450: Line 364:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | determined by SSR2 as a low priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 459: Line 371:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="background-color:#FFF; text-align:left;" | determined by SSR2 as a low priority

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Line 468: Line 378:

| style="background-color:#FFF2CC;" | P4

| style="text-align:left;" | implemented as part of [[Information Transparency Initiative]]

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

−

~~| style="background-color:#FCE5CD;" |~~

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" | TBD

| style="background-color:#FCE5CD; text-align:left;" |

Jessica

Bureaucrats, Check users, lookupuser, Administrators, translator

14,932

edits